Don't understand german? Read or subscribe to my english-only feed.

HAProxy with Debian/squeeze clients causing random “Hash Sum mismatch”

Update on 2015-07-02 22:15 UTC: as Petter Reinholdtsen noted in the comments:

Try adding /etc/apt/apt.conf.d/90squid with content like this:

Acquire::http::Pipeline-Depth 0;

It turn off the feature in apt confusing proxies.

” – this indeed avoids those “Hash Sum mismatch” failures with HAProxy as well. Thanks, Petter!

Many of you might know apt’s “Hash Sum mismatch” issue and there are plenty of bug reports about it (like #517874, #624122, #743298 + #762079).

Recently I saw the “Hash Sum mismatch” usually only when using “random” mirrors with e.g. in apt’s sources.list, but with a static mirror such issues usually don’t exist anymore. A customer of mine has a Debian mirror and this issue wasn’t a problem there neither, until recently:

Since the mirror also includes packages provided to customers and the mirror needs to be available 24/7 we decided to provide another instance of the mirror and put those systems behind HAProxy (version 1.5.8-3 as present in Debian/jessie). The HAProxy setup worked fine and we didn’t notice any issues in our tests, until the daily Q/A builds randomly started to report failures:

Failed to fetch Hash Sum mismatch

When repeating the download there was no problem though. This problem only appeared about once every 15-20 minutes with random package files and it affected only Debian/squeeze clients (wheezy and jessie aren’t affected at all). The problem also didn’t appear when directly accessing the mirrors behind HAproxy. We tried plenty of different options for apt (Acquire::http::No-Cache=true, Acquire::http::No-Partial=true,…) and also played with some HAProxy configurations, nothing really helped. With apt’s “Debug::Acquire::http=True” we saw that there really was a checksum failure and HTTP status code 102 (‘Processing‘, or in terms of apt: ‘Waiting for headers‘) seems to be involved. The actual problem between apt on Debian/squeeze and HAProxy is still unknown to us though.

While digging deeper into this issue is on my todo list yet, I found a way to avoid those “Hash Sum mismatch” failures: switch from http to https in sources.list. As soon as https is used the problem doesn’t appear anymore. I’m documenting it here just in case anyone else should run into it.

3 Responses to “HAProxy with Debian/squeeze clients causing random “Hash Sum mismatch””

  1. Jean Paul Says:

    Thanks! I’ve been running into this a lot lately, on various systems; Debian wheezy, Ubuntu 12.04 & 14.04.

  2. Petter Reinholdtsen Says:

    Try adding /etc/apt/apt.conf.d/90squid with content like this:

    Acquire::http::Pipeline-Depth 0;

    It turn off the feature in apt confusing proxies.

  3. mika Says:

    @Petter: oh wow, this indeed seems to solve the problem as well, thanks! \o/